January 5, 2025 - John MacDonald
The notion of one's eyes being opened in the bible is an important theme, meaning transformation. Adam and Eve's eyes are opened to their nakedness, as Paul/Saul's were opened to the wrongness of persecuting the early church. We see something similar wi ... Read Article
January 4, 2025 - John MacDonald
I was thinking last time about how the Jews thought God brought judgment against them historically through them being conquered. I'd like to apply this to the destruction of the temple in 70CE. This seems to be a big impetus for the gospels, and so Mark i ... Read Article
January 4, 2025 - John MacDonald
We often look at the idea of sin from the point of view of an individual’s personal shortcomings. In light of this modern interpretation of the individual, Jesus’s sacrifice as substitutionary atonement seems to make sense. But this is not ... Read Article
January 3, 2025 - John MacDonald
We thought previously about the pneumatikos or resurrection spiritual body of Jesus that would allow him to simultaneously indwell all believers as "Christ in You" to power you up in your spiritual fight against the tempter. In this conclusion I'll flesh ... Read Article
December 31, 2024 - John MacDonald
The interpretation of "Christ in You" being angelic possession as a haggadic midrash of the "excellent spirit" of Daniel 6:3 (being both the character of Daniel and the spirit that guided and empowered him), we noted the connection to the daimonion guidin ... Read Article
December 31, 2024 - John MacDonald
And Daniel was clothed in purple and was great and esteemed before king Darius, as he was knowledgeable and intelligent and a holy spirit was in him (Daniel 6:3, Old Greek)
And Daniel was above them, because an excellent spirit was in him, and the k ... Read Article
December 30, 2024 - John MacDonald
In 2011, Jesus Mythicism, the idea that Jesus never existed, was at peak popularity on the internet with sites like Neil Godfrey's Vridar and Project Reason's forum, and I was searching for scholarship engaging with Christ Myth theorist Earl Doherty, ... Read Article
December 29, 2024 - John MacDonald
Last time we looked a bit about Paul’s claim that Jesus was killed by the archons of this aion (rulers of this age), and this reflected the demonic spirits influencing Pilate and the Jews (eg., the crowd, the supreme council) against Jesus. This f ... Read Article
December 28, 2024 - John MacDonald
Jacob Berman and Godless engineer debated the historicity of Jesus tonight regarding Paul and other things:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lgEcgOzkOiU&t
I'm mentioning this because the passage in Paul of The Jews killing Jesus (which I first ... Read Article
December 26, 2024 - John MacDonald
In 2011 I was searching for scholarship engaging Christ Myth Theorist Earl Doherty, who argued Jesus never existed, and I found Prof James McGrath’s blog where he was critically blogging through Doherty’s book. For example:
Chapter 1 of Earl Dohe ... Read Article
December 25, 2024 - John MacDonald
Check out our 3 Mythmas posts for this year:
Christmas and Genealogies: The Adoption of Jesus by Joseph in Matthew and Luke
Merry Midrash: A Late Christmas Present with Dr Robert M Price
Did Jesus Have a Wife? Artificial Intelligence and the Virg ... Read Article
December 24, 2024 - John MacDonald
When we think about Jesus as the Messiah / King of the Jews, if we think of the virgin birth and Jesus being distanced there from the impurity of the sexual, I wondered what Grok 2 AI might say about sexuality and purity of such kings in the bible. Here' ... Read Article
December 23, 2024 - John MacDonald
It is generally accepted by scholars that the New Testament is in part imitative in nature (see The Jewish Annotated New Testament, for instance). This reflects the practice of mimesis from the Greeks (as Dennis MacDonald and Robyn Faith Walsh show, ... Read Article
December 21, 2024 - John MacDonald
So often when we consider the Christmas story we think of the Virgin Birth, but often overlook the bloodline genealogies. And this makes sense because if Jesus is not Joseph's blood child, why should we care about Joseph's genealogy in Matthew or Luke. ... Read Article
December 20, 2024 - John MacDonald
PREVIOUSLY:
Merry Christmas! Jesus’s Bloodline in Matthew
NOW:
There's another interesting feature of Matthew's genealogy. There are women in it who are associated with sexual immorality in the Old Testament, who Spong labeled the Shady Ladies ... Read Article
December 20, 2024 - John MacDonald
Want to know a fun fact? In Matthew's genealogy of Jesus (really of Joseph) we see Joseph adopted Jesus into a family with a Davidic royal bloodline. This fits in with the idea that Jesus was to restore the Davidic throne. God, after all, had promised the ... Read Article
December 11, 2024 - John MacDonald
Appendix: Response to Richard Carrier’s Review (2024)
In the few years since I wrote this essay there have been developments in what scholars call ‘the quest for the historical Jesus.’ One of the main contentions is that if we do not ge ... Read Article
December 11, 2024 - John MacDonald
A couple of years ago I published a critique of the Christ Myth Theory, which Richard Carrier responded to. Well, hit the refresh button because I've updated the essay with an Appendix that responds to Carrier. Check it out HERE! ... Read Article
December 7, 2024 - John MacDonald
Over the last few days, these two debates on the historicity of Jesus have popped up:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ick9jHp846Y&t
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7XLQN67Pto&t
I just watched Richard Carrier's friend Godless Engineer ... Read Article
December 2, 2024 - John MacDonald
In 2011 I was searching for scholarship engaging Christ Myth Theorist Earl Doherty, who argued Jesus never existed, and I found Prof James McGrath’s blog where he was critically blogging through Doherty’s book. For example:
Chapter 1 ... Read Article
December 2, 2024 - John MacDonald
As is clear from the genealogies of Jesus, both of which belong to Joseph, Jesus is adopted into Joseph's bloodline (since he isn't Jesus' biological father), just as the new believer is adopted into the family of God through Jesus who Paul calls the firs ... Read Article
December 2, 2024 - John MacDonald
APOCALYPTICISM AND MILLENARIANISM reflect the idea that the end of the age is at hand and would be followed by a judgment. This was the type of thing Jesus and John the Baptist were preaching. The world in which Jesus grew up that gave birth to this wor ... Read Article
December 2, 2024 - John MacDonald
As I note in my essay A Critique of the Penal Substitution Interpretation of the Cross of Christ , an extremely important aspect of the resurrection is that Christ as a spirit, Christ in you, could now possess the believer in a positive way as booster, th ... Read Article
December 1, 2024 - John MacDonald
In previous posts I noted how in Mark we have the satire of how the crafty Jewish leaders were manipulating scripture and tradition to invent a case against Jesus. Matthew shows something similar in one of Satan's temptations of Jesus misusing scripture. ... Read Article
December 1, 2024 - John MacDonald
I'm a little out of order today, Barber's essay being near the end of the book, but there were some things that are worth addressing now so here we go!
Jesus predicting his passion and resurrection is multiply attested to throughout scripture. Ho ... Read Article


