(14) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Synagogues by Anders Runesson
November 28, 2024 - John MacDonald
This essay is a general overview of synagogue life shaping the Jesus story. Runesson writes: These Jewish institutions, which were ubiquitous in the ancient Mediterranean world and, importantly, can be reconstructed based on sources both beyond and w ... Read Article
(13) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Scribal Galilee by Sarah Rollens
November 27, 2024 - John MacDonald
Rollens’ essay builds on the last one I talked about from Kloppenborg that examines the notion of the scribe in constructing the Jesus tradition.  She notes this argument only really pertains to the Q document, as the Gospels and Acts reflect a mor ... Read Article
(12) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Networks by John Kloppenborg
November 26, 2024 - John MacDonald
John Kloppenborg is one of the foremost experts on the "Q" source, the material common to Matthew and Luke that does not come from Mark. In this essay he tries to get beyond the notion of Jesus as the great genius to the idea that the gospel writings eme ... Read Article
(11) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Fame and Aura by Matthew G. Whitlock
November 26, 2024 - John MacDonald
The passage I would like to highlight in Whitlock's essay is: Historical Jesus scholarship must value multiple pieces without synthesis. We are not obligated to provide a complete, unified picture of Jesus. Mitzi Smith and Yung Suk Kim in Toward Decen ... Read Article
(10) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Chartism and the Forgotten Quests by James Crossley
November 25, 2024 - John MacDonald
This chapter was an occasion for me to reflect on Chartism and unjust death. Crossley notes for the Chartist interpretation of Jesus: Jesus’s death was regularly understood as an example of the unjust end that always awaits the benevolent reformer, ... Read Article
(9) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: The Late Latin Quest by Paula Fredriksen
November 25, 2024 - John MacDonald
A couple of passages stood out to me in this essay. Firstly, characterizing Augustine's thoughts on time: In that latter masterwork, time emerged as the great divide between humans—intrinsically time-bound and, thus, caught up in confounding proble ... Read Article
Ed’s 5th Secular Web / Internet Infidels Interview With John Dominic Crossan
November 24, 2024 - John MacDonald
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bleNU4mAJqg&t ... Read Article
(8) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Myth and Mythmaking by Stephen Young
November 24, 2024 - John MacDonald
Religious dispositions are not so much viewed as one’s subjective set of beliefs for the faithful but rather the way they experience the world, like how the world might appear/present itself to a schizophrenic in a conspiracy saturated way.  The re ... Read Article
(7) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: RELIGION, VISIONS, AND ALTERNATIVE HISTORICITY by Deane Galbraith
November 23, 2024 - John MacDonald
One of the great underreported sins of New Testament scholarship is the problem that, unless we're told by the writers, there is no way to tell whether specific interpretive units like the lord's supper or the empty tomb have their origins as historical m ... Read Article
(6) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Missing Pieces by Mark Goodacre
November 22, 2024 - John MacDonald
Some things mythicists point to is the lack of detail about Jesus in Paul, and Mark as allegorical literature. This, though, needs to be qualified in a way that favors historicity, not mythicism. Paul says he resolved to know nothing among you but Chris ... Read Article
(5) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Beyond What is Behind by Chris Keith
November 21, 2024 - John MacDonald
Keith gives an interesting example of how even if we consider something to be true of Jesus, there is so much that we still don't know. He writes: If I could indict atomistic approaches to the historical Jesus for one thing, it would be that their at ... Read Article
(4) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Biography by Helen K. Bond
November 20, 2024 - John MacDonald
Bond stresses the difficulty in trying to distill historical information about Jesus from the gospels. She writes: Thus the many chreiai in the Gospels are not primarily repositories of oral tradition, but fundamentally literary creations, crafted to ... Read Article
(3) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Beyond The Jewish Jesus Debate by Adele Reinhartz
November 18, 2024 - John MacDonald
One of the interesting things about this essay is some of the anti-Jewish overtones in the gospels may stem from literary need born out of the attempt to present universal saving by Jesus. Reinhartz writes: (1) Although the Four Gospels vary with res ... Read Article
(2) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Reception History by Halvor Moxnes
November 16, 2024 - John MacDonald
Blogging my way through the anthology, Moxnes has the first essay. One tidbit I'd like to highlight is how Jesus challenges societal norms. Moxnes writes: Jesus is calling young men to follow him and leave the patriarchal household and their father ... Read Article
Where Did Everything Come From?
November 15, 2024 - John MacDonald
My new Philosophy for Kids book is out today. Please pick up a copy! ... Read Article
The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus (INDEX)
November 14, 2024 - John MacDonald
I just got my copy with a whopping 32 essays in it so I will be blogging about the volume for a while. (2) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Reception History by Halvor Moxnes (3) The Next Quest For The Historical Jesus: Beyond The Jewish ... Read Article
Donald Trump full remarks at Inaugural National Faith Summit in Powder Springs, GA (Oct. 28, 2024)
October 29, 2024 - John MacDonald
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qTwBn4vh1o If you're intellectually impatient like me, just start watching at 47:00 when they start to stretch out their hands to cast a magic spell. That the faith community is backing Trump is wonderful. If Trump ... Read Article
Philosophy and the Will
October 28, 2024 - John MacDonald
"In Leibniz's sense, a ratio sufficiens, a sufficient reason, isn't at all a ground capable of supporting a being so that it doesn't straightaway fall into nothing. A sufficient reason is one that reaches and offers to beings that which puts them in the ... Read Article
Does Literary Imitation Suggest Christ Never Existed: The Trump Lens (2/2)?
October 26, 2024 - John MacDonald
Previous Posts in this Series: (1/4) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Continental/Analytic Philosophy Divide (Part 2 of 4) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Continental/Analytic Philosophy Divide (Part 3/4, AFTERWORD) Christian ... Read Article
(1/2) Does Literary Imitation Suggest Christ Never Existed?
October 26, 2024 - John MacDonald
It's now more mainstream to acknowledge that the NT writers were rewriting OT scripture to flesh out the biography of Jesus, and so we have Mark create his crucifixion narrative out of Psalms and Isaiah since Paul doesn't record any details. Matthew prese ... Read Article
Conservative Christians Trying to Cast a Magic Spell for Trump
October 24, 2024 - John MacDonald
Trump is polling well with conservative Christians but is really trying to overcome the problem that conservative Christians often stay at home on election day. ... Read Article
On the Essence of Hiding; or, Philosophical Truth
October 24, 2024 - John MacDonald
FOR THE SHORT INDEX OF MY PHILOSOPHY POSTS, SEE: The Joy of Philosophy (Postscript and Poetry) Heraclius: “physis kryptesthai philei” (Being/The Nature of things loves to hide) Hegel, in his inaugural address, Heidelberg, 1816, says “The ... Read Article
(Part4/4 Appendix) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Christ Myth Theory and the Lord’s Supper
October 22, 2024 - John MacDonald
I've been talking about how Paul introduced the Lord's Supper into the Jesus movement tradition as miming Jesus did alone in prison that represented a ritual meal for future Christians. The importance of Paul having this vision is it solidifies the idea ... Read Article
(Part 3/4, AFTERWORD) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Christ Myth Theory and the Lord’s Supper
October 21, 2024 - John MacDonald
For the first post in this series, see HERE For the second post in this series, see HERE (Appendix) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Christ Myth Theory and the Lord’s Supper (1/2) Does Literary Imitation Suggest Christ Never Existed? ... Read Article
(Part 2 of 4) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Continental/Analytic Philosophy Divide
October 20, 2024 - John MacDonald
For my previous post see HERE! For the Afterword in this series CLICK HERE (Appendix) Christianity, A Question of Reasoning: The Christ Myth Theory and the Lord’s Supper (1/2) Does Literary Imitation Suggest Christ Never Existed? Does Litera ... Read Article