The Best of Philosoraptor: John MacDonald’s Top Two Posts on Secular Frontier!
PHILOSOPHY (INDEX) How Johann Christian Friedrich Hölderlin Helped Us Rethink Ancient Thought RELIGION “The Next Quest for the Historical Jesus (2024)” Anthology by James Crossley (Editor), Chris Keith (Editor) – FINAL Updated Blogging Index
(Part 2) Martin Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy (Of the Event)”
PREVIOUSLY: (Part 1) Martin Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy (Of the Event)” As we continue with Heidegger’s Contributions book, we note it is not a linear development of an argument. Heidegger never intended it for publication. What I’m trying to show is his philosophy is not superstitious even though it uses theological language strategically. The later … (Part 2) Martin Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy (Of the Event)”
Review- The Letters of Paul in their Roman Literary Context: Reassessing Apostolic Authorship by Nina E. Livesey
SCORE 5/5 My thanks to Cambridge for providing me with a review copy of this book. PREAMBLE: LETTER TO PROFESSOR VINZENT Hi Prof Vinzent, My name is John MacDonald and I am president of the Secular Web. I recently posted a review of Prof Nina Livesey’s new book on the thesis of a fictional Paul and pseudonymous … Review- The Letters of Paul in their Roman Literary Context: Reassessing Apostolic Authorship by Nina E. Livesey
Jesus: Passover and the Feast of Unleavened Bread
Given that we are coming to the Season of Passover, it is appropriate to meditate on how the story of Jesus was formed to reflect Jewish scripture and tradition, and so is often unhistorical, e.g., Mathew invents stories about Jesus to portray him as the New and greater Moses. Moreover, Jesus is linked to the … Jesus: Passover and the Feast of Unleavened Bread
Critical Evaluation of William Craig’s 21st-Century Case against the Swoon Theory – Part 1
CRAIG’S 20TH-CENTURY CASE AGAINST THE SWOON THEORY In the 20th Century, the Christian apologist William Craig made a case against the Swoon Theory (which he refers to as the “Apparent Death Theory”) in these books: This case consisted of three objections: Craig’s Objection #2, the Sickly Jesus Objection, is the same as Objection #5 against … Critical Evaluation of William Craig’s 21st-Century Case against the Swoon Theory – Part 1
(Part 1) Martin Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy (Of the Event)”
Martin Heidegger’s Contributions to Philosophy reflects his famous philosophical “turning.” In this work, Heidegger returns to the question of being from its inception in Being and Time to a new questioning of being as event. Heidegger opens up the essential dimensions of his thinking on the historicality of being that underlies all of his later … (Part 1) Martin Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy (Of the Event)”
A Case Against the Swoon Theory in the McDowells’ Evidence For the Resurrection
THE CASE AGAINST THE SWOON THEORY IN THE RESURRECTION FACTOR In Chapter 6 of The Resurrection Factor (hereafter: TRF), published in 1981, Josh McDowell makes a case against the Swoon Theory, a case that draws on historical claims made in Chapter 3 of TRF. McDowell’s case against the Swoon Theory in TRF can be understood … A Case Against the Swoon Theory in the McDowells’ Evidence For the Resurrection
Reclaiming Heidegger’s Holderlin for our Secular Age: An Interpretation of Heidegger’s Elucidations of Holderlin’s Poetry
“We ask: How long then? So long that it even reaches beyond our present, godless age (Heidegger, Elucidations of Holderlin’s Poetry, 211)” We are looking at a poet from the lens of our secular age, Heidegger’s and Hölderlin’s theological language conveying a message that is also available to a secular reader. Hölderlin says “Gods who … Reclaiming Heidegger’s Holderlin for our Secular Age: An Interpretation of Heidegger’s Elucidations of Holderlin’s Poetry
What is Religious Life?
Today on “X (Twitter)’ Kant Specialist Prof Anita Leirfall posted about the nature of being religious and here is my response: Jesus is speaking here of how his teaching is an innovation of the Judaism of his time: 43 “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ … What is Religious Life?
Is Jesus God? The Esther Allusion
It seems that a straightforward reading of our New Testament sources does not equate Jesus with God as we would later see with the gospel of John and even later with the doctrine of the Trinity. For example, Jesus in desperate prayer in Gethsemane doesn’t seem to be praying to himself, just as Paul says … Is Jesus God? The Esther Allusion


